A pretty book with a confusing message
Armstrong, Jennifer. Magnus and the Fire. New York : Simon & Schuster Books for Young Readers, 2005.
Plot: Magnus works as one of a four-horse team at a fire station. They provide constant service, but cannot compete with changing technology. A motor engine replaces the team. Most of the horses accept going to pasture with good humor. Magnus, however, refuses to accept his retirement. He continuously escapes his field to join the firefighters. Eventually, he proves his worth, although he must make way for technology. A retired fire chief adopts him, allowing the faithful horse to eventually discover a sense of peace.
Genre: Picture Books, Animals, History
Reading Level: Grades 1-4
Similar Titles: Winter's Gift, Mrs. Mack
Personal Thoughts: While the text included beautiful and elaborate illustrations, the ending seemed a bit confusing. The story seems to focus on the ineptitude and limits of technology, but the motor vehicle stays while the horse must leave, despite his heroism and effectiveness. As a result, the story falls flat and leaves the reader disappointed.
No comments:
Post a Comment